With a wide-ranging menu encompassing the best of Italian cuisine (including tasty hand-tossed pizza), Brewster’s also mixes in “curveballs” like fish-and-grits and tikka masala chicken. A separate Wine Room seats 34 and is available for group events.

Brewster’s
11 W. Merchant Street
New Buffalo, MI
Ph.: 269-469-3005
https://brewstersnewbuffalo.com/