New Buffalo Vacation Rentals

Stay where Juniper began with our curated collection of New Buffalo vacation rentals. As one of Southwest Michigan’s most popular lakeshore destinations, New Buffalo blends beach-town ease with boutique shopping, harbor views, restaurants, nightlife, and easy access from Chicago and the surrounding Midwest.

Juniper’s New Buffalo properties include luxury-designed homes in some of the area’s most desirable settings, from downtown stays near shops and dining to lakefront retreats and spacious homes made for gathering. Each rental is selected for comfort, quality, and the kind of elevated guest experience that defines Juniper Holiday + Home.

Why Our New Buffalo, MI Properties Are the Best

New Buffalo stands out as Harbor Country’s lively lakeshore hub. Guests can spend the day at New Buffalo Beach, stroll the marina, book a boat day, browse local boutiques, or enjoy dinner and drinks at one of the town’s many restaurants. The area also offers quick access to wineries, breweries, golf, trails, casinos, and nearby communities like Union Pier, Grand Beach, and Three Oaks.

What makes New Buffalo different is its balance of convenience and energy. It offers the classic Lake Michigan vacation rental experience with more dining, shopping, and entertainment close by than many smaller neighboring towns. For guests who want beach access, walkable local favorites, and a polished home base in the heart of Harbor Country, New Buffalo is a standout choice.

With Juniper, your stay is supported by carefully maintained homes, thoughtful amenities, and a team rooted in the place where our story began.


Properties Available 12 properties available
Inside, light pours through tall windows and vaulted ceilings, setting an open, easygoing tone that carries through every level of the home. The great room is built for gathering, with plush seating, warm wood tones, and a fireplace that draws the room together without feeling formal. A separate sitting room offers wraparound views and a quieter pa
Sunny Dunes Retreat
Sunny Dunes Retreat
House Pet Friendly Location Grand Beach, MI
Bedrooms 5 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 14 guests
Rating 5 (2)
Enter a space of soaring ceilings, sun-drenched windows, and warm designer touches that make every room feel both polished and cozy. The living room is anchored by a two-story stone fireplace and filled with plush seating, perfect for movie nights or cuddling with the kiddos. Flowing effortlessly into the dining room and fully stocked chef-ready ki
Oasis in the Woods
Oasis in the Woods
House Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (6)
The amazingly beautiful, family-friendly Shore House is nestled on a bluff overlooking Lake Michigan, and every square inch has been designed for vacation bliss! The three-story home sits at the top of the hill, boasting never-ending million-dollar views. Backyard entertainment features are truly epic here, with a private white sand beach, a lower
The Shore House
The Shore House
House Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 5 baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating 4.9 (61)
This exquisite residence has been professionally designed and features cathedral ceilings crowned with several skylights, open social areas accented by a wood-burning fireplace, wide-plank hardwood floors throughout, and specially curated furnishings in every room. The completely remodeled kitchen has porcelain counters, a large prep island, high-e
The Songbird
The Songbird
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 4.9 (67)
Barefoot Cottage offers multiple inviting living areas where guests can spread out yet remain connected, from the bright main living room with vaulted ceilings, exposed wood beams, and warm hardwood floors on the upper level to additional lounge spaces perfect for movie nights or quiet conversation on the lower level. Large windows throughout fill
Hot HOT 402
Barefoot Cottage
Barefoot Cottage
House Pet Friendly Location Grand Beach, MI
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating 4.3 (3)
Tucked on a private wooded lot, the neighborhood’s gravel path leads you to an escape from the usual hustle and bustle. The elegantly decorated home takes its design inspiration from nature as well as a nod to an alpine hunting lodge. Deer Haus features bamboo floors in all first-floor living spaces, wood blinds, granite countertops, and KitchenAid
Deer Haus
Deer Haus
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 6 guests
Rating 4.9 (58)
Relax and recline in sumptuous leisure at the Moose House, a richly designed 6 BR/5 BA home just a stone’s throw from New Buffalo Harbor and Lake Michigan beaches. Your memorable family vacation or special weekend gathering is ensured here with a gorgeous Great Room and stone fireplace, a chef’s gourmet kitchen with a large marble-top island and wi
The Moose House
The Moose House
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 14 guests
Rating 4.9 (160)
Main Destination’s stunning open floor plan includes a gorgeous 2-story great room anchored by a stone fireplace flanked by large windows with motorized, remote-controlled shades. The gourmet, eat-in kitchen has a gas cooktop and an island that seats 4, with the adjacent dining table seating 8.Doors off the main social areas lead to a nice screened
Main Destination
Main Destination
House Pet Friendly Location Grand Beach, MI
Bedrooms 6 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 12 guests
Rating 4.9 (43)
Lake Michigan Getaway features a spacious open floor plan all on one level with a wall of windows looking out over the expansive backyard and Lake Michigan. The kitchen opens to the deck for easy indoor/outdoor entertaining and flows through to the living area, so everyone can enjoy each other's company and the glorious view.Each bedroom combines c
Lake Michigan Getaway
Lake Michigan Getaway
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 6 guests
Rating 4.9 (157)
The High Life has been newly renovated, and upon walking in, you’ll immediately be swept up by the elegant styling and open design of the interior space, which includes a gorgeous living room, dining room, and Family Room (affectionately called the Hearth Room), as well as a superb modern kitchen.Highlighted by great natural lighting and window vie
The High Life
The High Life
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 3 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 7 guests
Rating 4.8 (23)
Kiddos having fun while parents relax on the porch? Yes, please! Schoolhouse Rock is perfectly appointed for family getaways. An open social living area includes a fully equipped kitchen and plenty of space to relax, overlooking the pond. A cozy rock fireplace warms and relaxes during fall and winter stays. The primary suite is conveniently located
Schoolhouse Rock
Schoolhouse Rock
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (12)
Our guests commonly say they’re swept up by the combination of spaciousness, natural beauty, and elegant design found upon stepping through the doorway of Lodged in the Trees. From the Great Room’s vaulted ceilings and rustic cypress columns and trusses to the magnificent stone fireplace and large windows bringing in wonderful natural light, you’ll
Lodged in the Trees
Lodged in the Trees
House Pet Friendly Location New Buffalo, MI
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Half Bathrooms 1 half baths
Guests 9 guests
Rating 4.9 (30)

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree